Navigate
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Categories
    • Articles
    • Book Reviews
    • Interviews
    • Live Discussions
    • Podcast
    • Talks
  • Topics
    • Apologetics
    • Epistemology
    • Free Stuff
    • God
    • Moral Argument
    • Naturalism
    • Reformed Epistemology
    • Science
    • Street Epistemology
    • Theology
  • Events
    • Conferences
      • CCv1 Conference
      • CCv2 Conference
    • Events
      • CC Exchange 2022
  • Shop
  • Free Resources
  • FAQ
  • Get in Touch
  • Testimonials
  • Donate?
  • Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • SoundCloud
    • YouTube
Capturing Christianity
28K
15K
135K
12K
Capturing Christianity Capturing Christianity
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Topics
    • Apologetics
    • EAAN
    • Epistemology
    • Faith
    • Interviews
    • Live Discussion
    • Moral Argument
    • Naturalism
    • Science
    • Street Epistemology
    • Theology
    • Reformed Epistemology
  • Events
    • Conferences
      • CCv1 Conference
      • CCv2 Conference
    • Events
      • CC Exchange 2022
  • Shop
  • Info
    • FAQ
    • Testimonials
  • Get in Touch
  • Donate
0
does genesis teach the earth is young
  • Articles

Does Genesis Teach the Earth is Young?

  • December 21, 2016
  • 2 comments
  • 3 minute read
  • 2.3K views
  • Cameron Bertuzzi
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0

Does Genesis teach the Earth is young? During my recent trip to Israel I read a really great book; it’s a discussion between 5 Old-Testament scholars on the opening chapters of Genesis. In the book they lay out their views and briefly engage with each other, citing areas of agreement and disagreement. As an introduction, it’s definitely worth picking up. In any case, I wanted to note a few thoughts I’ve had while reading it.

John Walton has some really interesting things to say about Genesis 1 and 2. His interpretation has 2 primary components. First, Walton contends that Genesis 1 is not concerned at all about material origins (in other words, it doesn’t address how the physical world came to be). Instead, it serves to establish functional origins.

“What I have proposed is that in the ancient world and in the Bible something was considered to exist not when it took physical shape but when it had been separated from other things and given a name and a role within an ordered system. This is a functional cosmic ontology rather than a material cosmic ontology.” – John Walton

The first verse of Genesis, according to Walton (and Averbeck), is a literary introduction to–or overview of–the creation account; it is not a separate act of creation from the seven days. If this is correct, then the actual story of creation begins in verse 2 where material already exists, but function does not. He then argues that each day of creation notably lacks material connections. The primary role of the text is to establish function and give order to the cosmos.

Secondly, and less controversially, the cosmos is being ordered to serve as God’s Temple. “In the ancient world as soon as “rest” is mentioned in connection with God, everyone would have known exactly what sort of text this was: gods rest in temples, and temples are built so that gods can rest in them.” Day 7, the day of rest, instead of being undervalued, turns out to be most important. Rest does not indicate that God was physically exhausted from creating the universe; rest is possible because the cosmos is no longer chaotic but ordered so life can happen in normal, stable ways.

“In the ancient world as soon as “rest” is mentioned in connection with God, everyone would have known exactly what sort of text this was: gods rest in temples, and temples are built so that gods can rest in them.”John Walton

If the seven days of creation is essentially an inauguration ceremony of God’s temple–an account concerning functional rather than material origins of this cosmic temple–then Geneses as a whole contributes nothing to the question of the age of universe or the age of the Earth. This doesn’t mean God didn’t create everything, but that Genesis 1 and 2 is not telling that story. It’s telling a different, more interesting story.

Needless to say, Walton is not without his critics. However, I find his account particularly fascinating. Even if he is not correct about Genesis being solely an account of functional origins, the cosmos as God’s Temple indicates that we shouldn’t automatically assume the days of creation are meant to communicate sequential 24-hour days of material origins. We shouldn’t immediately assume that is what is being communicated. The primary story being told is one of God taking up residence in a universe he has personally created, ordered, and filled with people made in His image to serve as His temple.

About the Featured Image

An image of the sedimentary layers visible in the Grand Canyon. Another appropriate image for a discussion on the age of the Earth.
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
T A G S
  • Genesis
  • Science
  • Theology
Cameron Bertuzzi

Cameron is a professional photographer and founder of Capturing Christianity, a ministry aimed at exposing the intellectual side of Christian belief. He is a writer, speaker, and uses his ministry to host discussions and interviews on Christian Apologetics. Cameron is married to a beautiful wife and is the father of two adorable children.

SUBSCRIBE. BE AWESOME.

Get updates on new posts, upcoming live discussions, and more.

You May Also Like
View Post
  • Articles

CCv2 Apologetics Conference

  • Cameron Bertuzzi
  • June 8, 2022
View Post
  • Articles

CC Exchange 2022

  • Cameron Bertuzzi
  • February 7, 2022
View Post
  • Articles

Is Animal Suffering a Bigger Problem for Theists?

  • Seth Hart
  • February 3, 2022
View Post
  • Articles

The Teleological Menace, Why Biology (Still) Requires God

  • Seth Hart
  • December 11, 2021
Hummingbird
View Post
  • Articles

Btw, Evolution is Teleological

  • Seth Hart
  • November 23, 2021
View Post
  • Articles

The Gospels are Bíoi – So What? Three Lessons for Reading Them Well

  • John Nelson
  • October 26, 2021
View Post
  • Articles

Did American Christians Wage War on Darwin? (Spoiler Alert: No)

  • Seth Hart
  • October 11, 2021
View Post
  • Articles

Christianity’s War on Darwinism, or the War that Never Happened

  • Seth Hart
  • October 5, 2021
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Philip Rand
Philip Rand
4 years ago

Hi Cameron John Walton’s take on Genesis is incorrect… completely incorrect for many many reasons… for one thing the six days of creation are also referenced in Exodus… and here it is even more emphatic. So, a six-day creation is impossible to avoid! In truth the solution to six-days creation is trivial using science; absolutely trivial… so, trivial that I am surprised that not even a man like W L Craig with his intellectual abilities has not seen it! Just goes to show, that most philosophical solutions look one squarely in the face (probably the reason they are missed). I… Read more »

0
Reply
Cameron Bertuzzi
Author
Cameron Bertuzzi
4 years ago
Reply to  Philip Rand

I temporarily removed the Forums tab in the main menu, the forums themselves didn’t go anywhere. As you’ll notice, I’ve added it back.

Cheers.

0
Reply
about
Free 60-page eBook!
Join our super cool email list to receive a copy of our free 60-page eBook (and other cool stuff). Btw, Christianity is true.
Subscribe!
Trending Posts
  • 1
    CCv2 Apologetics Conference
    • 1
    • 1 min
    • 713
Support
If you find value in our content, prayerfully consider supporting us monthly on Patreon!
Follow Us!
Facebook 28K
Twitter 15K
YouTube 135K
Instagram 12K
582 53
Asking the real questions. 428 10
Because of all the work I do behind a computer screen, mowing my own lawn is one of the things I do to keep moving. I take a lot of pride in it :) 273 25
don’t @ me 992 130
It was so great meeting Joe and Alex in person! And of course it was great seeing Trent again. Who should we bring together for CC Exchange 23? 632 24
CC Exchange 22 is in full swing! The convo so far between Alex and Trent has largely focused on the problem of divine hiddenness. Yes, I’m recording it, and it will go on the channel soon. 284 25
Capturing Christianity
  • Home
  • Free Stuff
  • FAQ
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Donate?

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

wpDiscuz